Keeping out of the 'mommy trap'
Shared duty eases heavy responsibility
October 8, 2002
Maria Cortés Gonzalez, El Paso Times
It happens innocently.
Soon after becoming mothers, women automatically take on more responsibility.
And they don't ask for help from their husbands -- until they're feeling
overwhelmed.
Mother and author Julie Shields, who went through it, calls it "the
mommy trap." And in her book, "How To Avoid the Mommy Trap:
A Roadmap for Sharing Parenting and Making It Work," released last
month, she tries to help other couples avoid her mistakes.
"The main problem was I had unthinkingly taken more family responsibilities
than I had intended or that was working well for our family," said
Shields, who has two daughters, ages 6 and 3. "And that's one of
the most common arguments in a family -- over who does what in the family."
Unfortunately, many couples do not address the issue early enough.
"The most important thing that a woman can do is allow her husband
to get involved from day one," Shields said. "And a lot of
women don't do that. Men get pushed out right away and retreat to their
work."
El Pasoan Amber Ferguson, a stay-at-home mother of two children, ages
2 and 1, said she and her husband have good communication.
"If I have the feeling that I need extra help, I can tell him,"
she said.
Her husband is consistently helpful.
"When we had the second child, he was good about going places
and doing father-and-son outings to give me a little time," she
said.
Another stay-at-home mom, Olga Montes, said she sometimes feels the
pressure of taking care of four children, ages 6, 2 and 13 month-old
twins. "But once my husband comes home, he helps out with everything,"
she said.
Montes said she knows she can count on her husband for any task with
her children.
Shields believes it's important that couples talk about these family
issues before they get married. They should discuss what they think
their roles should be as parents and partners.
If you're already a family and the woman is feeling overwhelmed, she
can still make changes, Shields said.
"First, you need to figure out what you want to change,"
she said. "But you don't want to give him the grunt work."
Instead, ask him to help with one task that involves the children,
such as getting them ready for school.
And although it may be hard to resist, women must keep from criticizing
the help.
"If they dress the children in silly outfits, just remember, does
it really matter?" she said. "It doesn't."
What does matter is that children benefit from having their father's
involvement.
"Men parent differently; they tend to foster curiosity and give
children a little more space," Shields said. "And research
has shown that children are more secure when the two parents are involved.
And that's the best situation you can have."
Maria Cortés Gonzalez may be reached at cortes@elpasotimes.com


A Bookviews.com Pick of the Month
October 2002
" . . . the book is really about sharing parenting in order to
make family and work responsibilities balance out to the benefit of
both parents and the children. Having made most of the mistakes herself,
the author began to ask others how they make this situation work, then
moved onto various childcare professionals. This is really a primer
for couples considering marriage who need to determine if they are truly
compatible, for expectant mothers worried about both baby and career
commitments, couples who need new working arrangements, and, as noted
above everyone looking for answers to make everything work for all involved."


Maybe it's time to share some of the mother load
Thursday, September 12, 2002
Do you feel trapped by the responsibilities of motherhood and household
management? Do you resent your husband because he doesn't do much child
care and domestic work?
Julie Shields knows the feeling. An intellectual property attorney
and a freelance writer, Shields cut back on work when her first daughter
was born six years ago because her husband needed to put in the time
to develop his new career. Shields' mother watched the couple's little
girl while Shields worked 16 hours a week.
Then, when their daughter was 18 months old, Grandma had surgery and
couldn't baby-sit anymore.
"I was afraid,'' Shields said. "I had always considered myself
to be a person who wouldn't stay home. Working and my life at work were
part of my identity.''
Shields thought about what she wanted and needed out of her life. She
and her husband then had a discussion about how to proceed. She offered
to quit her job to stay home with their daughter, but with conditions.
"I told him I didn't want everything to fall into my lap all the
time,'' she said. "I told him I would cook dinner a couple of times
a week, he would cook, we would get takeout or go out, whatever.
"And whenever he was home, he would be responsible for my daughter.
I also put a time limit on it. My husband promised that when my daughter
turned 3, he would start to work flexibly or stay home. Things always
come up, but if you have an understanding, no one has to give up everything
all the time.''
When Shields started researching and writing her book "How to
Avoid the Mommy Trap: A Roadmap for Sharing Parenting and Making It
Work'' (Capital Books, $26.95), she found that one-third to one-half
of new parents experience as much marital distress as couples in therapy
for marital problems. She also found that new parents argue most about
what she calls "The Big Two": 1. Who does what with the kids
and the house? 2. Who makes the career accommodations on issues as large
as who stays home to care for preschool children or as small as who
cancels a meeting and takes off a workday when a child is sick? Even
women who don't consider themselves traditional may find themselves
volunteering to do all or most of the traditional "mothering''
responsibilities.
Be honest: Who buys the birthday party gifts in your house and who
takes the kids to the doctor? You may think you don't have a choice,
that all these domestic chores became your lot when you became a mother.
But, if you feel burdened by these chores and you haven't negotiated
with your spouse to lighten your load, you are doing a disservice to
yourself, your marriage, and your children, Shields argues. Maybe your
spouse has a flair for, say, cooking, and would do a great job if you
didn't criticize and just let him do things in his own fashion.
And maybe by doing everything you are depriving your children of one-on-one
playing and nurturing time with their dad.
Finally, as Shields points out, if a mother doesn't take into account
her need for personal satisfaction and just plain fun from the get-go,
the lack of those things will become a far greater issue as time goes
on.
We need to build in time when we walk away from our parenting role,
and let Dad assume the mantle of primary caregiver and household manager.
Shields even encouraged her husband to take a monthlong paternity leave
after the birth of their second daughter 3½ years ago.
"There really is a natural attachment that occurs between a father
and a child if the mother is not around to put herself between them,''
Shields said.
If you want to change the balance of your domestic responsibilities,
Shields recommends that you first take a personal inventory of what
you're doing vis-à-vis your children and your domestic chores.
"You need to understand how you got where you've gotten to,''
she said. "You need to think about what you want to change, what
you're capable of changing, and how you might be interfering with your
own goals for change."
Then, talk to your partner - not when you're in the midst of a domestic
meltdown, but when you can talk calmly, logically, and non-judgmentally.
Some couples she interviewed actually had written contracts specifying
how they shared responsibilities. For Shields and her husband, it's
more of an ongoing discussion, ever subject to change.
But the underlying premise remains the same: Shared parenting is good
for everybody, and moms shouldn't be martyrs to gender roles. For more
information, go to Shields' Web site: www.mommytrap.com.
The Pressured Parent runs on Sundays and Thursdays. You can reach Mary
Amoroso in care of The Record, 150 River St., Hackensack, N.J. 07601,
by fax at (201) 646-4047, or by e-mail at amoroso@northjersey.com. Please
give your name and number so she can talk to you.
4924584
Copyright © 2002 North Jersey Media Group Inc.

Who's Afraid of a Smart Woman
April 12, 2002
To the Editor:
In "The Baby Bust" (column, April 10), Maureen Dowd discusses
the difficulty that high-achieving women experience in dating, marrying
or becoming mothers. Yet many smart, assertive women are thriving in
a new type of courtship and parenting partnership. For a coming book,
I interviewed hundreds of couples who have managed to balance two sets
of personal ambitions, have children and put a lot of time into the
family.
In the human world of co-parenting akin to the society of bonobo
chimpanzees, which Ms. Dowd points to fathers and mothers have
sex more often, like and appreciate each other more and enjoy happier
unions. To do this, you must know what you want, ask for it, create
mutual flexibility and preserve a source of potential independence.
Today, women have more options, as do men, many of whom will respond
positively to a call for a different type of existence than their fathers
had.
JULIE SHIELDS
McLean, Va., April 10, 2002
Baby panic and drug tests
Readers respond to recent articles on Sylvia Ann Hewlett and mandatory
drug testing in public schools.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
April 26, 2002 | Read "A
Woman's Place" by Michelle Goldberg.
Michelle Goldberg's analysis of Sylvia Ann Hewlett's new book and the
accompanying media hoopla hits the mark. As I read article after article
discussing "the baby bust," I kept wondering whether all the
debate about the alleged fertility crisis [hadn't] been put to rest
in the last century, by Susan Faludi and others. Personally, I knew
that I had a greater chance of getting pregnant and married and having
a healthy baby in my 20s or early 30s, and didn't need to rely on any
survey to tell me so.
And, in research for my coming book, "How To Avoid The Mommy Trap:
A Roadmap For Sharing Parenting and Making It Work," I met many
high-achieving mothers who have it all, and love what they have. We
need to move beyond laments about how hard everything still is and instead
emulate those around us who have found a better balance of life, family
and work. Feminism has enabled today's women to design the lives they
want, a gift worth using.
-- Julie Shields